I had a feeling Moonlight would win the Academy Award for Best Picture this year. I was surprised when it didn’t. I was surprised again when it did.
Can it be true that we spent yet another Monday discussing yet another award-show blunder? This is becoming routine. Once again, with cameras rolling, America was treated to a most awkward moment when winners, faux-winners, presenters, hosts, and spectators were captured live looking left and then right trying to figure out how to get back on script when the script itself had apparently become part of the problem—at least for the presenters who incorrectly read them. Certainly, we remember choking on our drinks when Steve Harvey crowned the wrong contestant in the 2015 Miss Universe pageant. And we did the same this past Sunday night when Warren Beatty, Faye Dunaway, and the Academy boldly ushered the folks from La La Land to the stage only to politely nudge them aside so the staff of Moonlight could accept the best picture award instead, how ever contrived the moment now was. And then let us not forget the other incidents: Kanye West humiliating Taylor Swift at the 2009 MTV Video Awards (not to mention his numerous other on-air meltdowns) and Adele having not one but two on-air mishaps at consecutive Grammy Awards ceremonies. Plain and simple folks, it’s time to do away with live award-shows. The inevitability of human error necessitates the option of doing a thing over and getting it right. We do this in every other area of life where real-time performance is not essential. So why not in these cases? It would certainly be preferable to the on-air shipwrecks we’ve been witnessing lately.
But the most important thing is that while we enjoy making light of these mishaps, they’re not funny at all. At least they shouldn’t be. Although they spice up the drama for the gossips and provide punch lines to hack comedians, these blunders do more than tarnish the moment. They flat-out humiliate the faux-winners and at the same time break their hearts (imagine winning the lottery only to learn you shouldn’t have quit your day job so fast). These blunders also sully the triumph of the actual victors, whose “glory moment” now lacks all magic.
The real danger, though, is that our award programs are going to start losing credibility, which will hurt their respective industries and ruin an important part of American cultural expression, namely the celebration of our nation’s most beloved and talented artists. At this point, I can only hope the Academy and its presenters got all of the other awards right Sunday night. Because I have to be honest, I was kind of surprised when Denzel didn’t win.



